東京都美術館開館100周年記念【14回東京現展】江麗香〈秋聲賦〉彩墨中的時間書寫 水痕與秋聲 - Tokyo Metropolitan Art Museum 100th Anniversary Commemoration [The 14th Tokyo GENTEN]Water Traces and Autumn Sounds: The Writing of Time in Chiang Li-hsiang’s Ink and Color Paintings Written by WANG MUTI

Water Traces and Autumn Sounds: The Writing of Time in Chiang Li-hsiang’s Ink and Color Paintings

 

Written by WANG MUTI

I have always felt that humanity's comprehension of time is remarkably recent and incredibly clumsy. In our childhood, we know nothing of the "flowing years"; we only know dawn and dusk, cold and warmth, the bloom and wither of leaves, and the coming and going of stream water. It is only as we grow slightly older that we learn to use calendars, solar terms, eras, and various counting methods to bind that which is inherently unbindable, thus deceiving ourselves into thinking we understand time. Yet, the longer I live, the more I realize that time severed by numbers is merely a shadow convenient for human affairs, not its true essence. Where time truly forces us to acknowledge its existence is rarely in clocks, but in traces; not in minutes and seconds, but in flux; not at boundaries that can be proclaimed, but within those silent, slow passages that have long altered the form of things and the disposition of the human heart. Therefore, when I gaze at Chiang Li-hsiang’s paintings, particularly her two works The Flowing Years and Ode to the Autumn Sound, I cannot help but think: if time could indeed be painted, it would likely not appear as an abstract concept, but would manifest quietly—much like water leaving traces upon stone, or autumn finding its voice among vegetation—in a manner half-visible, half-audible, close to nature yet directly wired to the soul.

Scenery as the Vehicle of Flux

Chiang Li-hsiang’s ink and color, in my view, is most precious not because it merely depicts scenery, but because it transforms scenery into a vehicle for time. Viewers today are often eager to identify what is inside a painting: which mountain, which river, which tree, which path, which cloud, or which season—as if a work must first be clearly named to be understood. However, truly meaningful painting often refuses to submit entirely to this desire for identification. It does not rush to arrange the world in a tidy order; instead, it preserves the world in its state of alteration, transience, and mutual infiltration. Chiang Li-hsiang’s paintings belong precisely to this category. She does not rely on sharp contours to fix objects; rather, she allows water, ink, color, mist, light, shadow, and the absorption of the paper to entangle with one another, rendering the canvas in a state that is about to settle yet remains fluid, about to form yet remains incomplete, about to disperse yet remains intact. This state closely mirrors time itself. For time never reveals itself through fractures; it always manifests in transitions. Spring does not abruptly turn into summer overnight; peak vitality does not suddenly crash into decay; and the human heart rarely undergoes absolute, sudden mutations. For the most part, we are slowly reshaped into another form—unconsciously, by subtle currents, faint sounds, and water traces left inadvertently by the passing years.

The Flowing Years: The Form of Time

If we first consider The Flowing Years, its most moving aspect naturally lies in that continuous movement from top to bottom, far to near, dense to pale, and stone to water. The mountain rocks in the painting do not flaunt oddity through harsh steepness, nor does the water posture through dazzling waterfalls; yet, the entire painting possesses an un-interruptible downward momentum, as if time itself is quietly sliding along the textures of the world. The white cascading traces, the ash-brown rock patterns, the subtle hints of blue, and the damp mist wash over and reflect one another. This allows the viewer to see not just a scenery of a single moment, but a record of how stone is rewritten after countless flows, how water etches its own path into the earth, and how light temporarily lingers within each washing. This brings to mind that time's effect on humans is generally not found in monumental events, but in repetition and continuity. A person might not change entirely due to a single incident, but through repeatedly passing through, constantly being worn down, and enduring over time, they are finally sculpted into who they are today. The water in The Flowing Years is not merely natural water, but the water of experience; its stone is not merely mountain stone, but the stone of destiny. The two interact, neither able to detach from the other, just as a human life is both passed through by time and, through its own memory and endurance, endows time with a perceptible weight.

Ode to the Autumn Sound: The Whisper of Time

Yet, if The Flowing Years emphasizes the "form" of time, then Ode to the Autumn Sound comes closer to its "sound." The sound here, of course, is not an explicitly definable noise that merely reminds one of wind, leaves, water, or insects; it is more like a faint resonance carried along as a season quietly operates within all things. The beauty of autumn lies precisely in the fact that it is neither as brilliant as spring nor as harsh as winter; autumn always unfolds between brightness and darkness, blooming and withering, staying and leaving. Therefore, the sound of autumn is the hardest to paint, yet the most suited for ink and color. In this work, Chiang Li-hsiang does not seek victory through vibrant hues, but uses the receding of green, the hiding of yellow, the floating of grey, and the dispersing of white to construct an elusive atmospheric climate. The vegetation, slopes, mist, diagonal slashes, and low-lying shadows do not separate themselves with clear borders; instead, through bleeding and layered washes, they form a visual experience akin to hearing. Looking at this painting, one does not first discern "what scenery this is," but rather feels a certain sound slowly seeping inward from outside the canvas. That sound is not at the ears, but at the heart; it is not as distinct as thunder, but like the shifting of seasons, realized as genuine only after a long while. If The Flowing Years allows one to see how time walks, then Ode to the Autumn Sound makes one feel how time whispers.

The Symbiosis of Material and Existence

I am thus increasingly inclined to read these two works by Chiang Li-hsiang together. On the surface, one depicts the momentum of water while the other captures the mood of autumn; one leans toward motion while the other leans toward stillness; one resembles a cascade while the other resembles dense mist. Yet, at their depths, both belong to the same observation of time: time is not a straight line, not a simple progression, and not merely an abstract order moving from "before" to "after." Time is a prolonged operation that leaves traces in objects, forms climates in the senses, and slowly settles into perceptible matter within the soul. Thus, "water traces" and "autumn sounds," though belonging to sight and hearing respectively, are actually two identical developments of time. Water traces are the writing of time, while autumn sounds are its breath; the former is etched on stone, the latter is dispersed in the air; the former allows one to see its passage, while the latter makes one aware that it is currently happening. If an artist can capture both qualities simultaneously, she is not merely painting landscapes, but painting existence within seasons, and painting that deeper layer of life experience behind nature. The medium of ink and color on paper is also perfectly suited to this theme. While the color layers in Western painting can be thick, sculpting volume and constructing a solid order of light and shadow, for what Chiang Li-hsiang desires, the relationship between paper and water seems far more vital. The paper absorbs, the ink bleeds, the colors yield, and the water traces leave behind serendipity—which then becomes the background for the next layer of brushwork. Therefore, the value of ink and color lies not in absolute control, but in collaborating with the material. How similar this is to time. For human life is not entirely sculpted by will; more often than not, between the countless things we can and cannot grasp, we are slowly carried toward a certain form. Chiang Li-hsiang understands this temperament of ink and color deeply. Thus, her paintings neither lapse into affected abstraction nor fall into the rigidity of over-realism. She knows how to let the ink settle, let the color float, let the white breathe, and allow the boundaries to maintain a moderate drift. Consequently, the canvas naturally generates a breath akin to life: like everything in the world, it is not created by proclamation, but by incubation; it is not completed in one stroke, but finally grows its countenance through layer upon layer of flow.

The Subtle Infiltration of Maturity

I would even go a step further to say that Chiang Li-hsiang's writing of time does not belong exclusively to natural landscapes, but is closer to a self-awareness of existence. Has our life not also been spent amidst water traces and autumn sounds? Some experiences are like the flow upon stone: at first, we only feel the dampness, but later we realize it has already become a permanent trace. Some changes are like the sound in autumn: they do not necessarily make a thunderous name for themselves, but subconsciously cause a person’s luster, tone, obsessions, and way of seeing things to gradually shift into another season. When young, people mostly love to believe in decisive events, always thinking that major turning points must be accompanied by a great roar, and that changes in life must have a date to be commemorated. It is only when years deepen that we realize what truly makes us different is often not a grand declaration, but these finest, slowest, and least immediately perceptible infiltrations. Just as water is to stone, and autumn is to the forest, neither boasts of power, yet both conquer through continuity. Therefore, gazing at Chiang Li-hsiang’s paintings for a long time makes one think not only of nature, but of oneself. The damp whites, deep greens, grey-yellows, diagonal lines, gradients, and glimmers gradually cease to be merely external scenes; they become segments of an indescribable chronology once experienced within the heart, now translated into a form that can be stared upon. I have never much liked works where concepts come first while perception remains pale. For time is a topic that is far too easy to speak of grandly, yet far too difficult to truly feel. Anyone can talk about "the flowing years," "seasons," "flux," and "time"; but if the canvas itself cannot truly act upon the body, the senses, and the memory, even the finest title remains nothing but a title. Chiang Li-hsiang’s strength lies precisely in the fact that she does not rely on concepts to validate her paintings; instead, she lets the painting itself possess humidity, speed, climate, and stillness first, allowing the title to fall naturally upon it as a matter of course. Thus, The Flowing Years is not empty, because you indeed see the flux; Ode to the Autumn Sound is not hyperbolic, because you indeed feel a certain autumn resonance in the depths of your vision. This honesty of letting the imagery come first and allowing the meaning to grow later is precisely the rarest quality of a mature artist.

Conclusion

If I were to finally offer a comprehensive evaluation of these two works, I would say: Chiang Li-hsiang’s ink and color do not depict time; they allow time to leave itself behind. She has not painted the years into symbols, nor has she turned autumn into a cliché. Instead, through the extension of water traces, the subtlety of autumn sounds, the etching of rock textures, the floating of mist, the yielding of color layers, and the bleeding of ink, she ensures that time is no longer just an abstract concept, but an experiential reality that can be viewed, sensed, and even re-awakened by memory. In this way, the person before the painting is no longer merely a viewer, but someone touched by time: in The Flowing Years, realizing that they too have been slowly worn down and rewritten by the world; in Ode to the Autumn Sound, suddenly hearing those subtle voices within their own heart that have never made a great roar, yet have never once ceased over the years. Therefore, I wish to conclude this piece with these words: the so-called "water traces and autumn sounds" are actually two brushstrokes of time within nature and the soul. The former writes down passage, while the latter writes down feeling; the former teaches one to see how the years leave textures on external objects, while the latter teaches one to hear how the years generate echoes within. Chiang Li-hsiang’s paintings, existing precisely between these two, complete a writing that is unpretentious yet extremely durable. It does not rush to make people gasp in amazement, yet it is suited for prolonged gazing; it does not shock the ears with florid words, yet it remains long after viewing. If one can truly quiet down for a moment before these two works, one will understand: time has never moved forward solely on calendars; it also leaves wet traces on mountain rocks, disperses faint sounds in autumn forests, and, in those depths of life we have not yet had time to name, silently writes down the entire process of how we became who we are today.